There is a growing unease in conversations across the food and farming sector. Not just about sustainability in the abstract, but about something more immediate: volatility, fragility, and a creeping sense that the system we rely on is far less secure than we would like to believe.

George Monbiot’s recent piece captures this anxiety powerfully. His central argument, that the global food system has become dangerously concentrated, financialised and exposed to shocks, is hard to dismiss. When supply chains are optimised for efficiency rather than resilience, when production is concentrated in fewer hands and fewer places, and when critical flows move through geopolitical chokepoints, the system begins to resemble something brittle rather than robust.

History tells us what happens next. Systems don’t fail gradually; they fail suddenly, when a trigger exposes underlying weakness.

And yet, while the diagnosis is compelling, the prescription risks becoming overly binary.

The call to shift wholesale towards plant-based diets is understandable. There is no question that current levels of meat consumption, particularly from intensive systems reliant on imported feed, are environmentally costly and geopolitically fragile. Reducing consumption is both rational and necessary.

But removing livestock from the system altogether would be a mistake.

Livestock, when properly integrated, are not a weakness of the food system; they are one of its greatest potential strengths.

The issue is not animals per se. It is how we use them.

For decades, we have separated cropping and livestock into distinct, specialised systems. Arable farms have become increasingly dependent on synthetic inputs to maintain fertility, while livestock systems, particularly intensive ones, have become dependent on globally traded feed. In doing so, we have broken natural nutrient cycles and replaced resilience with dependency.

Reintegrating livestock into farming systems offers a different pathway, one that is grounded in biology rather than chemistry, and in circularity rather than extraction.

Well-managed grazing systems build soil organic matter, improve water retention, and enhance biodiversity. Animals recycle nutrients, reduce reliance on synthetic fertilisers, and create more resilient farming systems that can better withstand climatic shocks. Mixed farming systems, where crops and livestock coexist, introduce diversity, redundancy and flexibility back into the landscape: precisely the characteristics that resilient systems require.

Of course, this model requires a fundamental shift in consumption patterns. We cannot maintain current levels of meat consumption and transition to more extensive, regenerative systems. The arithmetic simply doesn’t work. We need to eat less meat, but better meat, produced in ways that enhance, rather than degrade, the system. This is where the real opportunity lies.

A rebalanced food system, one that combines lower overall meat consumption with regenerative livestock integration and a greater emphasis on plant-based foods, offers the potential for a genuine “win-win”. It reduces pressure on global supply chains, lowers input dependency, rebuilds soil health, and enhances long-term resilience.

The challenge, however, is that this transition will not happen organically. The current system is deeply shaped by powerful economic interests, input suppliers, processors, and global traders, whose business models are built around scale, standardisation and throughput. A shift towards more diverse, locally adapted and biologically driven systems runs counter to those incentives.

Left to “the market”, change will be slow and partial at best. This is where policy plays a critical role. Not in dictating outcomes, but in creating the conditions for transition: incentivising soil health and mixed farming, supporting farmers through the risks of change, investing in knowledge and advisory systems, and aligning supply chains to reward resilience rather than just efficiency.

Equally important is the role of collaboration. Farmers, food businesses, financiers and policymakers all have a stake in building a system that can withstand shocks. Trust, relationships and shared understanding, often undervalued and difficult to quantify, become essential infrastructure in this context.

Because ultimately, resilience is not just a technical challenge. It is a human one.

The lesson from nature is clear: systems that endure are diverse, interconnected, and adaptive. Our food system has drifted too far in the opposite direction, towards simplification, concentration and optimisation at the expense of resilience.

We do not need to choose between plants and animals, or between productivity and sustainability. That framing is part of the problem. What we need is a more intelligent integration of both.

A system that produces less, but better; that works with natural processes rather than against them; and that is designed not just for efficiency in good times, but for stability in uncertain ones.

Because the real risk is not that George Monbiot is wrong. It’s that he might be right, and that we fail to act in time.

Photo by Wolfgang Hasselmann on Unsplash