We are measuring our way towards disaster while the planet burns on our doorstep. On the eve of another Earth Overshoot Day, it’s time to stop writing reports and start acting, together.
Duncan Rawson, EFFP Partner
A few years ago, in the strange, suspended summer of 2020, I wrote about Earth Overshoot Day for the first time. If you missed it, the premise is simple and sobering. It marks the day each year when humanity has used up everything that nature can sustainably provide and renew within 12 months. Everything after that date is borrowed from future generations. Back then, COVID-19 had contracted our footprint and pushed the date back to late August, a grim silver lining if ever there was one.
Tomorrow, 30 July, marks this year’s Earth Overshoot Day.
Now here’s the thing. If you look at where the date has fallen over the last fifteen years or so, it has more or less plateaued, hovering within a fairly narrow window. Good news, I suppose. Except it isn’t. The damage from overshoot is cumulative; every year we spend in deficit adds to the last. On a consistent measure, this year’s overshoot is the largest ever recorded. We are, on current reckoning, consuming nature as though we had 1.73 planets to draw on. We do not. We have one.
So a steady date is not the same as a steady planet. It simply means we have found a comfortable altitude at which to keep falling.
Let me be clear, though. I am not writing this to wallow. There is real cause for optimism in our own industry. The agri-food sector is, in places, making genuine progress. There are some excellent initiatives taking root. The likes of Nestlé and Weetabix, to pick two standouts, are doing serious, thoughtful work on regenerative sourcing and back-to-farm sustainability that would have seemed fanciful a decade ago. That deserves recognition.
But, and it is a very big but, we are still only scratching the surface. And if I am honest, that worries me deeply.
It worries me because here we sit in the third heatwave of the year, in the third year of compromised harvests out of the last five. It worries me because we are watching wildfires spread, not in some far-flung place we can comfortably read about over breakfast, but on our own doorsteps. It worries me because geopolitics has meant the foot has come off the gas, just when we needed to press harder, and the strategies and initiatives meant to mitigate climate change have quietly slipped down the agenda. It worries me because, as a society, we are becoming steadily unhealthier, continually fed food that compromises our health by businesses fixated on short-term financial return. And it worries me because we see report after report from organisation after organisation, each faithfully documenting the same problems and, more often than not, prescribing the same solutions, yet nothing changes. If we poured half as much energy into doing something, anything, as we do into producing yet another report, we might actually get somewhere.
And it frustrates me that, as an industry, we have talked ourselves into an endless loop of measurement, MRV, baselining, benchmarking, as though the act of measuring the problem were the same as solving it. It frustrates me that millions, indeed billions, are being spent by organisations lobbying hard to protect a profit-rich status quo, hampering the very systems change we so badly need. And it frustrates me that too many companies simply follow the pack, chasing the latest buzzword or the newest initiative, rather than sitting with the harder, longer question of what genuine, systemic change would actually require.
And yes, I can see the irony. Here I am, writing yet another blog, issuing yet another call to action, doing the very thing I have just spent several paragraphs complaining about. But of course, my thoughts and ideas are far better than everyone else’s. Obviously.
But that aside, here is what I believe, and I believe it passionately.
I believe, above all, that we need a systems approach. Not another single-issue crusade, not another silver bullet, but a whole-system rethink of how food is grown, moved, sold and eaten. But that does not mean waiting for the perfect grand plan before we move. The little things matter, because the little things are how a system shifts, one changed practice at a time. Doing something, anything, beats doing nothing.
In that piece back in 2020, I argued that almost every problem we face, environmental, economic, societal, comes back to a single root cause: a lack of diversity. A lack of biodiversity in our soils and our farming systems, a lack of diversity in our diets, and, just as corrosively, a lack of diversity in our thinking. I stand by every word. If anything, I would put it more strongly now. Diversity, in all its forms, is not a nice-to-have bolted onto the side of a sustainability report. It is the beating heart of a food system resilient enough to survive the shocks that are, quite plainly, already here.
That drive to collaborate is the hard part because it runs counter to so much of how our industry is wired. We need to suspend, at least for a while, our relentless pursuit of competitive advantage and truly collaborate. Work together. Share the risks, and share the rewards. Do things because they are right for society and for our own long-term resilience, not merely because they buy us a short-term edge over the business down the road.
And we need to be honest about the harm we cause, and face into it together. That means the agricultural industry as much as the food industry. Farmers can no longer stand back and say, “give us the money and we’ll do as we’re asked.” We have to take responsibility for the damage caused by the farming systems many of us adopted over the past decades, and for putting it right. Not alone, but by working alongside others, sharing the risks and the benefits of doing so. As someone who started out in farming in the early 1980s, I include myself squarely in that reckoning.
None of this is comfortable. It requires brave thinking. It requires real collaboration, the kind where we share not just the platitudes but also the risks, costs, and benefits. At EFFP, this is precisely the work we have been doing for years: helping food and drink businesses build genuinely collaborative supply chains, and, increasingly, back-to-farm sustainability initiatives that add real value rather than simply adding another line to another report.
We are up for this. Are you?
If you’d like to talk about what that might look like in practice, please don’t hesitate to get in touch: drawson@effp.com or 07834 337346.
