An article written by EFFP for Agritrade News.

“If you are unwilling to disrupt yourself, there will always be someone willing to disrupt your business for you.”  – Marc Randolph, Netflix Cofounder

Back in 2000, Blockbuster, a store-based movie rental business, turned down an offer to buy an upstart mail-order subscription movie rental business called Netflix for $50 million.  Blockbuster didn’t want to ‘disrupt’ their operating model delivering 50% gross margins with Netflix’s measly 30%.  As technology shifted to let Netflix stream video over the internet, Netflix has grown to be worth over $300 billion, while Blockbuster went bankrupt in 2010.

The current farming system has provided plentiful, affordable food for decades.   But today, around the world and in the UK, there is an existential crisis facing farming.   Farm profitability is struggling.   Subsidies are being cut.   Extreme weather events are occurring regularly.   Inputs are expensive, and some are becoming less effective.  Lack of diversity and deteriorating soil health has left us increasingly exposed to disease, pests, and extreme weather.  Increased sustainability requirements from buyers and regulators are creating more work for no additional pay.    Many farmers are trapped in a high cost, high risk system, with the odds getting worse.

Given this backdrop, will the farming landscape see more disruption than the movie rental business did when streaming came along?  Or less?

“The future is already here, it’s just not evenly distributed.” –William Gibson, Canadian-Amercian Sci Fi Author

Downstream food businesses are increasingly committing to reducing greenhouse gas emissions in their supply chain. As they work to reduce emissions and environmental impacts, farm inputs such as chemical fertilisers and crop protection products are in their sights.  Likewise, if farmers are to be economically and environmentally sustainable, they need to reduce costs, build resiliency, and produce the food their customers want.

How will the agri-input sector adapt?   Or, put another way, how will the industry be disrupted by these changing downstream requirements?

Progress has been made on low-carbon fertilisers, which may be part of the solution.   However, more needs to be done to reduce the amount of energy and water used in the process to lower the cost.  Biological plant protection products can offer a more environmentally sustainable alternative than chemical pesticides, but costs need to come down to drive their wider scale adoption.  More investment may go into plant breeding and seeds, but again, they need to enable farmers to be more profitable overall.

Is regenerative farming a fad or an opportunity? 

 A recent analysis of over 79 global food and retail giants, worth over USD $3 trillion and representing almost a third of the sector, showed that nearly two-thirds of companies have publicly stated they are adopting regenerative agriculture initiatives (FAIRR 2023).

The agroecological or regenerative farming movement, operating on a low- input, low-cost model which enhances nature as food is produced, is growing and being incorporated into EU and UK farm policy.   The big question for readers of Agritrade News is “What impact will that have on the input supply model?”     Some in our industry have seen the regenerative farming movement as an opportunity and have launched their own programmes, but their core business remains focussed on the sale of inputs. How far will they go?  Will they disrupt themselves to actively encourage a reduction in inputs?  Is it possible to build a model based on monetising knowledge to help farmers adapt to the changing environment rather than one simply focused on the sale of inputs?

We can’t predict the future.  However, we would encourage businesses across the agrifood supply chain to think hard about how the farming context is changing and to ask themselves whether there is a danger of them  becoming the next “Blockbuster” if they don’t adapt in time.

We don’t know all the answers at EFFP but we do have a deep understanding of agri-food issues and facilitating strategic change.  Do get in touch if you’d like to know more.

For over 20 years, EFFP have helped agri-food businesses develop and implement strategic change, including strategic reviews, business planning and behavioural change.  For more information, please visit effp.com or email Peter Wortsman at pwortsman@effp.com.